ЧАСТЬ (22)

 

Вокруг измышлений востоковедов  и заблуждений сторонников вестернизации (2)

 

Также противники Ислама при определении «сунны» акцентируют своё внимание на языковом значении понятия (путь). Так, в своём определении они говорят, что «сунна» представляет собой практическую сторону образа жизни, ограничивающуюся только поступками. Слова, невысказанные одобрения и качества Пророка (мир ему и благословение Аллаха), в соответствии с таким определением, не являются Сунной. Приверженцы этого мнения считают, что употребление слов «хадис» или «сунна» в их терминологическом значении (слова Пророка (мир ему и благословение Аллаха), его действия, невысказанные одобрения, описание его внешности и нрава…) является нововведением со стороны учёных в области хадиса и что арабский язык якобы не знал таких значений и они не употреблялись в арабских стихах. Такое заявление сделал Махмуд Абурейх[1] в своей книге «Адуа’ ‘аля ас-сунна аль-мухаммадийя»[2], поддержав мнение доктора Тауфика Сидки[3].

 

Подобные заявления высказал и доктор Аль-Мухандис Мухаммад Шахрур[4] в своей книге «Аль-китаб уа аль-Кур’ан, кыра’а му’асыра»: «Определение пророческой Сунны представляет собой жизнь Пророка (мир ему и благословение Аллаха) в качестве пророка и человека, который не просто прожил реальную жизнь, а был в центре событий. Таким образом, это не было иллюзорным миром». В другом месте он заявил: «Поэтому мы считаем ошибочным определение Сунны Пророка (мир ему и благословение Аллаха) теми, которые сказали, что она представляет собой всё то, что исходило от Посланника Аллаха (мир ему и благословение Аллаха): слова, поступки, повеления, запреты и невысказанные одобрения. При этом необходимо учитывать, что сам Пророк (мир ему и благословение Аллаха) не давал такого определения, и поэтому его можно оспорить, в чём-то согласиться, а в чём-то нет. Данное определение (, которое дали учёные в области хадиса,) стало причиной мумификации Ислама, учитывая, что ни Пророк (мир ему и благословение Аллаха), ни его сподвижники не давали такого определения. И поступки Умара ибн Аль-Хаттаба подтверждают это»[5].

 

 

 

[1] Махмуд Абурейх – египетский публицист, в молодости обучался в образовательной системе университета «Аль-Азхар». После того как перешёл в среднюю школу при «Аль-Азхаре», не смог добиться успеха в учёбе. Работал редактором типографских ошибок в местной газете. Затем до самой пенсии – в городском местном управлении. Среди его трудов, в которых он подверг критике Сунну и сподвижников:  «Адуа’ ‘аля ас-сунна аль-мухаммадийя», «Кисатуль-хадиси аль-Мухаммади», «Шейх аль-мудайра (имея в виду Абу Хурайру)». См. «Ас-Сунна уа маканатуха фи ташри’», доктор Ас-Субай’и, с. 466.

 

[2] «Адуа’ ‘аля ас-сунна аль-мухаммадийя», с. 39.

 

[3] Доктор Мухаммад Тауфик Сидки, врач, обслуживающий тюрьму в Каире. Публиковал свои статьи в журнале «Аль-манар» под рубрикой «Ислам – это только Коран». Умер в 1920 году. Мухаммад Рашид Ридо опубликовал его биографию в журнале «Аль-манар», 483/21 и последующих выпусках. См. журнал «Аль-манар», 11/774.

 

[4] Мухаммад Шахрур, сирийский современный публицист. Получил докторскую степень в инженерном деле в Народном Ирландском университете в Дублине. Среди его трудов: «Аль-китаб уа аль-Кур’ан, кыра’а му’асыра», «Аль-ислям уа аль-иман манзуматуль-кыйям», «Государство и общество».

 

 

[5] «Аль-китаб уа аль-Кур’ан, кыра’а му’асыра», с. 546-548.

Comments  

#699 ЧАСТЬ (22) Вокруг измышлений востоковедов и заблуждений сторонников вестернизации (2)Margie 2023-09-24 06:10
Thanks for finally writing about >ЧАСТЬ (22) Вокруг измышлений востоковедов и заблуждений
сторонников вестернизации (2)
Quote
#698 ЧАСТЬ (22) Вокруг измышлений востоковедов и заблуждений сторонников вестернизации (2)Wilburn 2023-09-23 19:18
Thanks on your marvelous posting! I truly enjoyed reading it, you
can be a great author. I will make sure to bookmark your
blog and may come back someday. I want to encourage you to definitely continue your great work, have a nice holiday weekend!


Feel free to surf to my homepage คาสิโนออนไลน์: https://www.codechef.com/users/heng99u
Quote
#697 ЧАСТЬ (22) Вокруг измышлений востоковедов и заблуждений сторонников вестернизации (2)Bret 2023-09-22 20:25
Good info. Lucky me I found your website by chance (stumbleupon).
I've bookmarked it for later!

my page; แทงบอล: https://linktr.ee/heng99u
Quote
#696 ЧАСТЬ (22) Вокруг измышлений востоковедов и заблуждений сторонников вестернизации (2)Wilson 2023-09-22 09:36
Howdy! Someone in my Facebook group shared this site with us so
I came to check it out. I'm definitely loving the information. I'm
bookmarking and will be tweeting this to my followers!
Outstanding blog and wonderful design.

My site: เช่าชุดแต่งงาน: https://doodleordie.com/profile/weddingshopz
Quote
#695 ЧАСТЬ (22) Вокруг измышлений востоковедов и заблуждений сторонников вестернизации (2)Joanne 2023-09-19 20:48
Hmm is anyone else having problems with the images on this blog loading?
I'm trying to find out if its a problem on my
end or if it's the blog. Any feed-back would be greatly appreciated.


Also visit my webpage - Pay Per
view: https://Wiki.Unionoframblers.com/index.php/User:NilaAhmed2391
Quote
#694 ЧАСТЬ (22) Вокруг измышлений востоковедов и заблуждений сторонников вестернизации (2)Selene 2023-09-17 00:12
Please let me know if you're looking for a article writer for your
weblog. You have some really great posts and I believe
I would be a good asset. If you ever want to take some of the
load off, I'd really like to write some material for your blog in exchange for
a link back to mine. Please send me an e-mail if interested.
Thank you!

My webpage - Example Of Retirement Wishes: http://aaahe.com/index.php?page=user&action=pub_profile&id=229
Quote
#693 write my essay paper for me u78kaqHectorallok 2023-09-15 11:57
Wow lots of good knowledge!
online dating profile writing service uk best online essay writing services reviews essay writing service quora mental health writing service science resume writing service writing public service announcements for radio how have you grown as a writer essay how to write an about me section for a website online essay writer uk write my essay same day
Quote
#692 pay to do my essay s24urgHectorallok 2023-09-14 03:50
This is nicely expressed. !
naukri resume writing service review essay on helping the poor i need help writing an essay english essay help cheap essays help student room essay writing service cheap essay help me write an essay cheap essay writing help helping essays
Quote
#691 ЧАСТЬ (22) Вокруг измышлений востоковедов и заблуждений сторонников вестернизации (2)Alycia 2023-09-13 15:46
If you are going for finest contents like me, just pay a quick visit
this web page daily as it offers quality contents, thanks

My website daily calendar planner: https://gravesales.com/author/jonelle70i9/
Quote
#690 professional essay writer g59fscHectorallok 2023-09-12 23:30
Perfectly expressed without a doubt. !
what is the last phase of writing an informative essay community service thesis statement debate thesis master thesis writing service uk masters thesis help essay writting service how should i do my homework homework help cpm my homework do my statistics homework free
Quote
#689 what to write my college essay on x31ynqHectorallok 2023-09-11 13:56
Superb material. Appreciate it!
essay writing service article essay help cheap college essay help online essay help cheap help with writing college essays writing essay service writing service essay admission essay services report writing service linkedin profile writing service australia
Quote
#688 what to write in about me for dating site m15hpdHectorallok 2023-09-11 11:46
Really plenty of very good material!
writing an informative essay cheap essay help: https://englishessayhelp.com/ essay writing service essay help: https://essaywritinghelperonline.com/ help with nursing essays best uk essay writing service reviews buying college papers: https://bestpaperwritingservice.com/ college paper writing services best research paper writing services in usa: https://bestonlinepaperwritingservices.com/ research paper writing service free
Quote
#687 pay somebody to do my essay u62oftHectorallok 2023-09-10 05:52
Thank you. I like this.
essay writing service quote college essay service college essay writing service near me dissertation proposal writing service writing a business plan service custom dissertation writing service buy essay online reviews essay papers for sale where can i buy essay paying someone to write a paper
Quote
#686 can someone write a research paper for me r63tduHectorallok 2023-09-10 03:53
Thanks a lot. Numerous knowledge.
best statement of purpose writing service uk dissertation writing help co: https://dissertationwritingtops.com/ phd thesis writing services uk buy dissertations online: https://helpwritingdissertation.com/ psychology dissertation help professional essay writing services uk cheap write my essay: https://hireawriterforanessay.com/ best website that writes essays for you do my essay: https://theessayswriters.com/ hire someone to write my essay
Quote
#685 write a paragraph for me using these words i791cyHectorallok 2023-09-08 22:53
Appreciate it! Lots of posts.
college paper writing service case study paper writing service philosophy essay writing service high quality custom essay writing service pro essay writing service writing a business plan service buy cheap essays pay someone to write an essay for you buy an essay paper online pay someone to write my essay
Quote
#684 what can i write about for my essay c73almHectorallok 2023-09-08 20:36
Kudos, Excellent stuff!
sat writing essay can i do my homework on an ipad: https://domyhomeworkformecheap.com/ do my college math homework do my english homework: https://domycollegehomeworkforme.com/ i didn t do my homework what do i do high quality article writing service custom essay for sale: https://quality-essays.com/ pay for writing essay buy cheap essays online: https://buyanessayscheaponline.com/ cheap essays to buy
Quote
#683 free college essay writer f28wwzHectorallok 2023-09-07 14:05
This is nicely expressed. !
writing a narrative essay about being judged quizlet write my dissertation theses and dissertations online i need help with my dissertation dissertation experts political science essay writing service write my essay free online essay writers online cheap what can i write about for my essay what to write in about me in resume for freshers
Quote
#682 write an essay for me g56wtzHectorallok 2023-09-07 11:13
You actually said that exceptionally well!
essay writing service america thesis statement words: https://customthesiswritingservice.com/ thesis statement summary i need a thesis statement: https://writingthesistops.com/ thesis statement for personal essay professional essay writers professional dissertation help: https://dissertationwritingtops.com/ dissertation assistance services proposal writing companies: https://helpwritingdissertation.com/ phd thesis proposal
Quote
#681 ЧАСТЬ (22) Вокруг измышлений востоковедов и заблуждений сторонников вестернизации (2)Ida 2023-09-06 02:38
Thank you for some other great article. Where else may just anybody get that type of information in such a perfect means of writing?
I have a presentation next week, and I am at the look for such information.

Look at my web blog :: 2025 calendario: http://egg-lover.com/?option=com_k2&view=itemlist&task=user&id=53551
Quote
#680 fast essay writer o86krlHectorallok 2023-09-05 23:15
You have made your point quite clearly!.
writing a memorial service program psychology dissertation statistics help doctoral dissertation help qualitative cheap dissertation writing dissertation websites professional cv writing service free someone to write my essay for me write an essay for you writing a persuasive essay what website writes essays for you
Quote
#679 help me write an essay for free n328rpHectorallok 2023-09-05 17:56
Amazing tons of useful tips.
b2b content writing service dissertation essay writing service: https://topswritingservices.com/ pilot resume writing service writing an impressive nursing entrance essay samples: https://essaywriting4you.com/ cv writing service dublin help with college essay writing writing a community service essay: https://essaywritingservicelinked.com/ essay writing service uae professional cv writing service uk: https://essaywritingservicetop.com/ top quality essay writing services
Quote
#678 ЧАСТЬ (22) Вокруг измышлений востоковедов и заблуждений сторонников вестернизации (2)Wiley 2023-09-03 15:18
I have learn some good stuff here. Certainly value bookmarking for revisiting.
I surprise how so much effort you place to create the sort of great informative site.



Here is my blog post - Calendario de Septiembre: https://www.campingiceland.com/community/profile/malorieoconor13
Quote
#677 cheapest essay writers c44mbpHectorallok 2023-09-01 18:24
Superb info, Appreciate it.
essay writing service reliable order of an essay buy cheap essays online pay for essay cheap pay for essays online will writing service horley phd thesis writing services phd thesis writing services india buy dissertation writing services writing a dissertation in 3 months
Quote
#676 pay somebody to do my essay o48cmnHectorallok 2023-09-01 15:28
Amazing a lot of amazing tips.
how to advertise resume writing service service quality thesis philippines: https://argumentativethesis.com/ thesis help phd thesis proposal writing service: https://bestmasterthesiswritingservice.com/ thesis for critical analysis dating site profile writing service cheap paper writing services: https://service-essay.com/ research paper essay writing service buy school papers online: https://custompaperwritingservices.com/ history paper writing service
Quote
#675 ЧАСТЬ (22) Вокруг измышлений востоковедов и заблуждений сторонников вестернизации (2)Harrison 2023-08-30 22:37
I visit daily some websites and sites to read posts, but
this web site offers feature based writing.

Also visit my blog: printable daily calendar 2023: https://www.planetpillars.com/community/profile/sylviajefferis/
Quote
#674 ЧАСТЬ (22) Вокруг измышлений востоковедов и заблуждений сторонников вестернизации (2)Terry 2023-08-30 07:39
My brother recommended I would possibly like this web site.
He was totally right. This submit actually made my day.
You cann't believe simply how much time I had spent for this info!

Thanks!

Feel free to surf to my website kalender ausdrucken: https://leedonss.com/2023/03/16/kostenloser-kalender-zum-ausdrucken-fur-2024/
Quote
#673 my essay writer net d72paxHectorallok 2023-08-29 15:30
Amazing a good deal of valuable data.
best phd writing service who can write my essay: https://essayssolution.com/ irving i ll write the song you sing for me do my essay for me uk: https://cheapessaywriteronlineservices.com/ expert essay writer e writing service phd paper: https://helpwithdissertationwriting.com/ phd dissertation proposal buy dissertation introduction: https://dissertationwritingtops.com/ phd thesis writing services uk
Quote
#672 write and essay for me n94hocHectorallok 2023-08-29 14:42
Thanks a lot. I enjoy this!
finance essay writing service write my essay for free write my extended essay for me how to write an about me for dating site do my english essay for me paper writing service in us custom written term papers buy research paper urgently research project proposal phd research proposal
Quote
#671 who can i pay to write a paper for me l63wpyHectorallok 2023-08-28 18:46
This is nicely expressed. .
legal essay writing service top paper writing service: https://bestpaperwritingservice.com/ collage paper writing service where to buy resume paper: https://bestonlinepaperwritingservices.com/ writing service for research paper economics essay writing service essay writing service canada: https://topswritingservices.com/ cheap assignment writing service best essay writing service: https://essaywriting4you.com/ law assignment writing service
Quote
#670 in a good narrative essay the writer makes a point j792jnHectorallok 2023-08-28 18:15
Wow a good deal of valuable material!
academic essay writing thesis writer thesis development engineering thesis writing service philosophical thesis statement writing a personal essay buy essays online cheap pay for paper writing buy essay order custom essay online
Quote
#669 essay writers online m543olHectorallok 2023-08-27 21:54
You actually reported this well.
law enforcement resume writing service writing service essay: https://essaywritingservicehelp.com/ college entrance essay writing service essay writing service quote: https://essaywritingservicebbc.com/ cio resume writing service what is the best essay writing service uk psychology thesis topics: https://argumentativethesis.com/ phd thesis on customer service english thesis writing: https://bestmasterthesiswritingservice.com/ thesis stament
Quote
#668 write a bibliography for me m12rynHectorallok 2023-08-27 21:38
Good forum posts. Appreciate it.
mba essay writing service india writing a good thesis thesis correction service bosto engineering thesis writing service thesis literature review essay writing service uk dissertations help dissertation help uk review dissertation pay help writing your dissertation
Quote
#667 write my essay 4 me o49uzpHectorallok 2023-08-27 02:48
Nicely put, Cheers.
cover letter writing service sydney buying college essays: https://quality-essays.com/ buy admission essays pay for research papers: https://buyanessayscheaponline.com/ buy nursing essay free online will writing service college essays for sale: https://payforanessaysonline.com/ buy my essay buy essay: https://buycheapessaysonline.com/ buying essay
Quote
#666 introduce yourself as a writer essay o32gpqHectorallok 2023-08-27 02:44
This is nicely put! .
professional curriculum vitae writing service research papers to buy business proposal writing service writing services for research papers mla research proposal best rated essay writing service college thesis elevator repair service thesis thesis binding thesis for essay
Quote
#665 someone to write my essay t525flHectorallok 2023-08-26 09:35
With thanks! Lots of postings!
best essay writing service reddit college papers writing service resume writing service silicon valley best seo article writing service writing services for essays writing a customer service cover letter buy essay online cheap custom research papers for sale buy custom essay pay someone to write my essay
Quote
#664 can you do my essay for me y65myiHectorallok 2023-08-26 09:25
You said it adequately.!
free will writing service charity college papers for sale: https://essaypromaster.com/ paper writing services write my paper for money: https://paperwritingservicecheap.com/ paying someone to write a paper best essay writing service reddit essay paper writing services: https://studentessaywriting.com/ writing essay write paper service: https://essaywritingserviceahrefs.com/ writing services
Quote
#663 write a lab report for me x29pekHectorallok 2023-08-25 15:20
Nicely put, Thanks a lot.
is essay writing service legal professional essay writing best master thesis writing service cheap essay writing good essay writing service oxbridge personal statement writing service write essay service writing a business plan for cleaning service best college essay writing service low price essay writing service
Quote
#662 write a thesis for me p296izHectorallok 2023-08-25 14:46
Factor nicely regarded..
essay writing service reviews forum writing dissertation tips: https://phdthesisdissertation.com/ i hate my dissertation online dissertation writers: https://writeadissertation.com/ art dissertation help essay service reviews cheap essays for sale: https://quality-essays.com/ best website to buy essays essays for sale: https://buyanessayscheaponline.com/ buy essay help
Quote
#661 ЧАСТЬ (22) Вокруг измышлений востоковедов и заблуждений сторонников вестернизации (2)Ashley 2023-08-25 13:06
It's remarkable designed for me to have a site, which is valuable in favor of my experience.
thanks admin

Also visit my page 2024 kalenteri: http://hanvituro.kr/board_qfar77/403084
Quote
#660 pay someone to do my essay f98qpdHectorallok 2023-08-24 17:27
Many thanks. A good amount of stuff!
customer service business email writing research paper writer write a research paper write my research paper cheap write my paper in 3 hours freelance article writing service college paper service cheap academic paper writing service professional paper writing service how much to pay someone to write a paper
Quote
#659 what should i do with my life essay g33myvHectorallok 2023-08-24 16:36
Thanks! I value it!
age uk will writing service essays for sale online: https://payforanessaysonline.com/ buy essay paper pay someone to write my essay: https://buycheapessaysonline.com/ essays for sale engineering thesis writing service cheapest paper writing service: https://service-essay.com/ paper writing service for college students college paper writing service online: https://custompaperwritingservices.com/ customer writing paper service
Quote
#658 write a descriptive essay on farming in my town v43yspHectorallok 2023-08-23 19:13
You explained that effectively!
article writing service pay to do my essay buy original essays online essay on sale buy narrative essay monthly blog writing service custom essay writing services canada reviews cheap essay writing service uk professional essay writing cheap essay writing service uk
Quote
#657 writing an opinion essay n372drHectorallok 2023-08-23 18:09
Incredible a good deal of great data!
cv and linkedin profile writing service uk cheap essay service: https://essaywritingservicelinked.com/ essay writing service co uk review trusted essay writing service: https://essaywritingservicetop.com/ best essay writing service cheap cv writing service uk dissertation help: https://phdthesisdissertation.com/ dissertation assistance uk phd.research: https://writeadissertation.com/ proquest dissertations
Quote
#656 ЧАСТЬ (22) Вокруг измышлений востоковедов и заблуждений сторонников вестернизации (2)Earl 2023-08-22 21:31
What's up friends, its fantastic post on the topic of teachingand fully defined,
keep it up all the time.

My page - พนันบอล: https://isft.kr/bbs/board.php?bo_table=free&wr_id=238014
Quote
#655 my essay writer i402vzHectorallok 2023-08-22 19:40
Many thanks. Great stuff.
assignment writing service review thesis editing: https://argumentativethesis.com/ claim/thesis psychology thesis: https://bestmasterthesiswritingservice.com/ thesis writing service reviews essay writing sites best online essay writing services: https://studentessaywriting.com/ monster resume writing service discount extended essay writing service: https://essaywritingserviceahrefs.com/ best paper writing service reviews
Quote
#654 ЧАСТЬ (22) Вокруг измышлений востоковедов и заблуждений сторонников вестернизации (2)Dacia 2023-08-22 09:28
Good day! I could have sworn I've been to this site before but after looking
at a few of the posts I realized it's new to me.
Anyhow, I'm certainly happy I discovered it and I'll be book-marking it
and checking back often!

Feel free to surf to my web site; บอลออนไลน์: https://w.ocmjerez.org/question/unlock-your-maximum-victorious-capability-with-our-expert-football-betting-expertise/
Quote
#653 ЧАСТЬ (22) Вокруг измышлений востоковедов и заблуждений сторонников вестернизации (2)Freddy 2023-08-22 06:46
Yesterday, while I was at work, my sister stole my
apple ipad and tested to see if it can survive
a forty foot drop, just so she can be a youtube sensation. My iPad is now destroyed
and she has 83 views. I know this is totally off topic but I had to share it
with someone!

Also visit my site: พนันบอลออนไลน์: https://tyrrst.com/unveiling-the-key-to-awesome-on-the-net-soccer-betting-odds/uncategorized/
Quote

Add comment

Security code
Refresh